Friday, December 16, 2022

William “Billy” Mitchell: A Man of Great Action and Ideas

 Guest Post by Lori Martello

            William Mitchell was more than the man our Milwaukee airport is named after, for Mitchell was a prominent figure beyond the notorious court martial that made him seemingly more famous than his revolutionary ideas during the First World War and during the interwar period. George Hardie, Jr., a Milwaukee aviation historian, Army veteran, and author of General William Mitchell: Air Power Pioneer, wrote the following regarding how Mitchell should be received:

“General Mitchell can be well regarded as the American herald of a world revolution. With that revolution war and transport moved into a new dimension. Mitchell, with many others, saw it coming. However, unlike the many, he did something about it, advancing aviation in ways that are recognized here and abroad.”[1]

Like Hardie’s commentary on Mitchell, Major Alfred F. Hurley, a former Air Force Brigadier General and former chancellor of the University of Northern Texas, wrote that Mitchell was the pivotal character in the history of the World Wars as his ideas and actions made him unique and indispensable to the future of warfare:

“When Mitchell is considered in terms of his ideas, he emerges as one of the significant figures of the years between World War One and Two…Many of his ideas span an era which will not end until the missile replaces the airplane as the primary carrier of nuclear weapon.”[2]

What has been intensely studied surround the topic of Mitchell was his 1925 court martial, wherein he attacked the United States Navy for their supposed responsibility in the disaster that was the USS Shenandoah. Yet what other historians have sought to prove is that Mitchell was a man of great action and ideas that was constantly stalled by the War Department and the Army in the interwar years. There are various biographies on Mitchell that portray his boisterous character and parallel it with the court-martial, yet what the following historians advocate for is the revolutionary aspect of his ideas that made his boisterous, passionate, and outspoken manners and attitudes make sense.

            To being to understand how Mitchell became known as the Father of the United States Air Force, one must be aware of his exceptional actions prewar, during the First World War, and in the interwar period. Plainly stating, Mitchell was a man who enjoyed acquiring knowledge, and his learning and application of said learning made him a fierce leader and expert. His experience in the Spanish-American War made him a soldier, but the time he spent learning would foster his ideas on the future of combat and supported his insistence on a unified Air Force. Mitchell even paid for his own flying lessons in Kansas, which then cost him $1,470. Under General MacArthur, Mitchell laid 75 miles of telegraph lines in the Philippines and later 1,700 miles in Alaska; and it was during this time that he later recounted his first thoughts of “blitz” warfare. Emile Gauvreau, an American journalist and author, in his 1942 book, Billy Mitchell: Founder of Our Air Force and Prophet without Honor, credited Mitchell as the creator of the blitz due to his time spent in Alaska and the Philippines; Gauvreau recounts conversations Mitchell had regarding the “flaming coffins” that himself and others would attempt to fly. Mitchell spent his time touring Russian, Japanese, French, and Germany warcrafts in his youth prior to the outbreak of the First World War. He wrote in the Cavalry Journal in 1906 about how his tour of the far north culminated in his ideas about aviation: “Conflicts no doubt will be carried on in the future in the air, on the surface of the earth and water, and under the water.”[3] What historians have made clear is that Mitchell spent his time forecasting military future in terms of how aviation would be the factor that determined success.

During the early years of the First World War before American entry, Mitchell, through his own financial and social means while still working for the War Department, advocated for and created a loose aviation department for the U.S. Army. It was his time in Paris that really originated Mitchell as a war hero and annoyance: “Though Washington placed little value on Mitchell’s views on aviation, the French regarded him as an authority. He once lectured the French Senate committee on aviation.”[4] The United States appropriated $1,650,000,000 for aircraft and all Mitchell got was 196 planes, so he used his own finances to relocate to a bigger headquarters in Paris. Socially, Mitchell acquired prospective aviators as the War Department would leave his messages unanswered. Mitchell absorbed and generated ideas and asked endlessly shrewd questions that fed into the character which was popularized during his court martial in 1925.

His actions during the First World War cemented him as a hero not only because of his actions at Saint Mihiel, wherein he led an air armada of French, British, and Italian flyers to successfully halt Germans, but because he was an organized and dedicated soldier that was in those “flaming coffins” similarly to his soldiers. Mitchell was the first American officer to fly over battlelines. According to Burke Davis, “Mitchell used his organization plans of St. Mihiel for the new offensive, improving his communication system between airfields and other points by radio, telephone, and motorcycle couriers.”[5] And while he was not regarded as heroically to the War Department, the soldiers perceived him differently: “The fliers around him would have done anything for him…and so would the boys out in the squadrons…Billy was clearly the Prince of the Air now.”[6] Mitchell spent the war years flying over enemy lines to report back to commands on the how aviation and his fleet could alleviate the pressures on the ground forces. His success during the First World War impacted his behavior, attitudes, and perspectives in the future that have been used to sensationalize the events leading up to his court martial.

Major Alfred F. Hurley and Emile Gauvreau seem to be the biggest proponents that seek to establish Mitchell as a man of ideas and knowledge that speak the great depths and impact of Mitchell. Hurley claims that the sensationalism of the certain events of Mitchell do not do justice to the revolutionary ideas that Mitchell contributed: “All of Mitchell’s biographies have tended to overemphasize one or two sensational elements in his history, particularly his court martial…When Mitchell is considered in terms of his ideas, he emerges as one of the most significant figures in the years between World War One and World War Two.”[7] Mitchell spent the interwar years studying and even predicting the events of the Second World War in particular the events of Pearl Harbor, and Emile Gauvreau spends copious amounts of time setting up his book Billy Mitchell: Founder of Our Air Force and Prophet without Honor in a way that presents the then current events of war (1942 specifically) in retrospect, in retrospect to what Mitchell predicted: “Everything he [Mitchell] told us right here has come true – the battleships sunk by air bombs, big cities like Cologne destroyed from the air, France gone, the Philippines gone, just as he said seven years ago, sitting right at this table.”[8]

What is greatly interesting is that Mitchell advocated that aviation would be a valuable adjunct to the Army – “a second line of defense,” if the Navy, “the first line of defense” should fail to stop an invasion, and he advocated for this with ideas that were well researched, thoroughly detailed, and had an overall theme of the strengthening the American military. And what historians have romanticized in some ways was his passion and outspoken character that got him court martialed as he spoke out against the Navy regarding the crash of the USS Shenandoah. What the above mentioned historians and authors have offered is a way of viewing Mitchell for his passionate ideas surrounding aviation and not solely his 6,000-word press statement that blamed the Navy for the deaths of the 14 crewmen on the USS Shenandoah. For Mitchell spent his career and life vehemently finding ways to foster American success in war, and Mitchell’s ideas paired with his success in the air give credence to him being referred to as the Stormy Petrel of the Sky and the Father of the United States Air Force.

           

 

  

 

 



[1] George Hardie, General William Mitchell, Air Power Pioneer (Milwaukee, WI: Ken Cook Transnational, n.d.), 19.

[2] Hardie, General William Mitchell, 18.

[3] Burke Davis, “I Am Naturally a Sort of Soldier,” in The Billy Mitchell Affair (Delanco, NJ: Notable Trials Library, 2003), 19.

[4] Burke Davis, “Good Men…Running Around in Circles,” in The Billy Mitchell Affair (Delanco, NJ: Notable Trials Library, 2003), 31.

[5] Burke Davis, “Good Men…Running around in Circles,” in The Billy Mitchell Affair (Delanco, NJ: Notable Trials Library, 2003), 39.

[6] Cohen Lester & Emile Gauvreau, “The Creator of the Blitz,” in Billy Mitchell: Founder of Our Air Force and Prophet without Honor (LULU COM, 2019), 29.

[7] Alfred F. Hurley, “Introduction,” in Billy Mitchell, Crusader for Air Power (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1975), p. viii.

[8] Lester & Gauvreau, “The Creator of the Blitz,”  13.


Digital Reenactment

 Guest Post by Henry Stull

        Reenacting a historical event, or a historical timespan as in our case, on Twitter is a very interesting and unique way of applying in-depth analysis of primary sources. In a more traditional assignment such as an essay or presentation, the research by its very nature has to be a lot more eclectic and diverse in order to present an informed project. For example, to write a paper about the economic development of the Egyptian old kingdom, the author of that paper would have to have at least a rudimentary knowledge of geology, metallurgy, permaculture, and animal husbandry, in addition to the usual set of skills which comes with doing history work. Whereas in a traditional paper might have me look for arsenic concentrations in malachite mined in the Sinai peninsula, the Twitter reenactment pushes the focus more onto the chronology of events. The multi-disciplinary element is still hugely present in the Twitter reenactment, especially with characters who played laborers such as the plankman/railman. However with John Mitchell, who was largely a political actor, research mostly fell under the purview of the social sciences. Local history makes it really easy to show how large, sweeping movements affect small, localized realities and vice versa.

            Seeing as chronology is very important to maintain, especially when working collaboratively and instantaneously with large numbers of people, I oriented my tweets around John L. Mitchell’s Wikipedia article. The benefit of organizing my tweets around the entry helped establish a character arc and portioned away the diversity dynamic eras of John Mitchell’s life. There were also some tremendous sources in the course bibliography about his time serving in the Union army. If Wikipedia was the skeleton for my tweets, then the meat and muscle came from both the class bibliography and the Library of Congress’s digital archives. John Mitchell was very popular amongst his peers in the Senate (until he wasn't) and there is a great trove of his speeches and correspondence, such as a famous one where he rails against the US annexation of the Hawaiian archipelago. I probably drew the least from the class bibliography because a lot of the information about John was physical and also in Madison for some reason, I had requested the box, but I do not think it ever arrived. Despite this, however, the class bibliography was probably the most valuable in terms of the Twitter assignment because the descriptions of his letters really gleaned off a lot of his personality. A banker who was against financial interests; a progressive who fought for business interests so long as they were local industry; scion heir of the wealthiest family in Wisconsin yet pursues a career in agriculture; John L. Mitchell seems like a tangle of contradictions! He lived in a state of educated confusion and self-righteous hypocrisy which ironically contributed positively to his strong moral character. He was a good guy and I enjoyed portraying him.


Experiencing the UWM Special Collections

 Guest Post by Cameron Neubauer

My research was focused on Ruth Mitchell, sister of Billy Mitchell. Thanks to the class bibliography, I had a primary source that I knew I wanted to use right away. I went to the online database for archival collections at UWM and found that they had Ruth’s book, My Brother Bill, in Special Collections. One afternoon I went to the Special Collections department and asked to see the book. There was a list of rules for the material including no drinks or food, and no picking the material up off the table. I signed off on the rules and sat at the table. Once they brought the book out to me, I was surprised by how well kempt it was. The cover was battered only slightly, and the pages barely had any folds or wear. It was shocking to see the price tag on the book as well for $4.00 compared to prices today, but it makes sense considering the book was published in 1953. After surveying the condition, I began flipping through the pages. In the beginning was a page honoring the memory of four John Lendrum Mitchells in the family. There is an introduction by US Air Force Lieutenant General Gerald W. Johnson which was honorable as well and made the whole book seem slightly less biased. I began using my phone Notes app to scan the entirety of the book with every page. It took quite a bit of time, but it ended up being worth it for my classmates and I to read the book with ease. The reading was relatively easy to follow and enjoyable because Ruth didn’t use scholarly vocabulary and kept to a chronological timeline of Billy’s life. Overall, My Brother Bill is an interesting book to pick up not only for research purposes but for recreational reading too.

Primary Sources on Popular Figures: Many Interpretations

 Guest Post by Lori Martello

        Throughout the course of this semester, finding and analyzing primary sources surrounding the popular figure Billy Mitchell in the army and during the First World War was difficult as the sources found were mainly published secondary sources rather than published primary sources. Key published primary sources surrounding Billy Mitchell, like his 6,000-word press statement after the crash of the USS Shenandoah and his War Department memos that revealed his attitudes to superiors and the Navy, have been selectively published to further notions of his behaviors and reputation as a tenacious and provocative leader and war hero. Specifically, there are many secondary sources published by the Air Force Historic Foundation that focus on his character and temperament that made him a successful leader.

Hoping to discover archived primary sources to yield more key sources that had not been published or widely cited to fit into the narrative of Billy Mitchell, the Stormy Petrel of the Air, the UW-Milwaukee Archives Special Collections was very helpful. In the collection of the Mitchell Family Papers, 1864 – 1968, Billy was already a war figure, hero, and fervently fighting for organized aviation, and so there were unfortunately no primary sources in this collection that focused on his time in the War Department or his correspondence with his family that had not been cited frequently; the collection did have reference to the movie that was based on Billy Mitchell’s court martial in 1925, titled The Court Martial of Billy Mitchell. The second useful source at the UWM Special Collections Department was Billy Mitchell’s book, Winged Defense: The Development and Possibilities of Modern Air Power – Economic and Military, published in 1925. The difficulty in using this book, and with many archives, is that none of the sources focusing on Billy Mitchell were either digitized and made available online and that scheduled appointments were needed to view these sources. The accessibility and inaccessibility of sources will seemingly forever be a problem for students and archives, but a great methodological approach to finding unpublished or less popular primary sources was to look at the footnotes and reference pages of secondary works.   

            Additionally in this process, analysis of the sources found regarding Billy Mitchell during the First World War encouraged different interpretations of Mitchell. As the character and brief history of Mitchell was focused on in class prior to this primary source process, analysis of primary sources enabled for attentiveness, a deeper study to contrast the time in which the writings took place with the time span of the narrative. And as many of the sources found were life narratives of Mitchell, his experiences, and interpretations of the past, then present, and future, this process enabled for evaluation of Mitchell’s objectives during his time during the war, in the interwar period, and after his court martial.

A Trip to the UWM Archives

 Guest post by Natalie Hernandez

Before His450 I conducted primary research on one other occasion for another class. We were encouraged to go to the UWM archives or use a primary source form the digital collections. I decided to pick a digital primary source to work with because I was nervous to physically go to the archives. When Professor Seligman told the class that we would work with primary sources I was nervous but excited to get to learn more about approaching primary source research.

When the class was assigned to find a primary source, we wanted to analyze and present at the Milwaukee Public Museum (MPM), I made an appointment at the UWM archives. You don’t need to make an appointment, but it is recommended. The day we were assigned the assignment we went to the UWM library so that a library staff member could teach us a method to approach primary source research which made the assignment more approachable. We went over a research analysis method called “Six Thinking Hats” which taught the class tips on how to analyze primary sources.[1] We also learned how to use a UWM finding aid to help us decide which boxes we should look through to find a primary source regarding our topic. This lesson made me feel more equipped to go to the archives by myself and look for a primary source.

Before heading to the archives, I used the finding aid to look for primary sources related to the Mitchells and found a collection called the “Mitchell Family Papers.” I looked at the boxes and their description and noted three that I wanted to look through. Once I was at the archives, I approached a staff member and explained that I was there for a class assignment and needed assistance getting a box. The staff brought me the box containing the “Mitchell Family Papers” along with folder dividers to use as place holders when I’m looking through the documents. The staff advised me to handle the documents gently and to keep the documents organized and in their respective folders. As I looked through the primary sources, I came across hundreds of postcards and letters with cursive handwriting I had trouble reading. After half an hour of mostly admiring the postcards, I decided to use an invitation from the president to John L. Mitchell to attend a boat christening ceremony for the U.S. Wisconsin. Along with the invitation there was a newspaper clipping that covered the event. I thought it would be a good set of primary sources to analyze and explain at MPM. After I decided on the sources, I asked the staff member if they could scan them and email the scans to me. I left once the documents were scanned and emailed to me. I left the library feeling good about my experience at the archives.



[1] “Six Thinking Hats,” Wikipedia, retrieved December 14, 2022, from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Six_Thinking_Hats.

 

Tuesday, December 6, 2022

Calvin Coolidge

 Guest Post by Eli Norlander

Calvin Coolidge became the 30th president of the United States following the sudden death of President Warren G. Harding in 1923. Before his role as Vice President, he had a career in both the State Senate and House of Representatives for Massachusetts. He was well regarded in both the growing Progressive Party and Republican Party. This was because he consistently ran as a Republican but had strongly held views that the Progressive Party valued, most notably, women’s suffrage. He wrote a piece titled “Have Faith in Massachusetts,” in which he appealed to the political importance of Massachusetts both to the United States and also the world in how it set the example for a strong economy and government leaders that had strong church ties. This piece was very highly thought of in his state, which propelled Coolidge to the office of Lieutenant Governor for two years and then Governor of Massachusetts for two more, before being selected as Harding’s running mate. Well documented as a shy, more introverted individual, during the campaign, Coolidge would travel throughout the northeast US, only allowing small crowds of people he was familiar with to hear his concise speeches. Also historically documented, the office of Vice President holds few powers, and this worked well for “Silent Cal.” He was the first Vice President to sit in on cabinet meetings, which allowed him to sit and observe. He was known as a well-spoken individual when he did choose to speak publicly. Warren G. Harding passed away, leaving Coolidge to take over a cabinet that included divisive individuals like Herbert Hoover, who eventually would lead the nation into the Great Depression, and Albert Fall, who was exposed for the Teapot Dome scandal.

Coolidge is relevant to the Mitchell family due to his conflict with Billy Mitchell. He was focused primarily on limiting government spending and reducing the budget of the federal government. This did not align with Billy Mitchell’s goals of establishing a separate branch of the military for air power and air travel research. It was under his administration that Billy Mitchell was court martialed, tried, and convicted of felonies due to his outspokenness and detailed press activity documenting Coolidge’s decisions. While Billy Mitchell was very outspoken in his opposition to Coolidge, the President did not respond in great volume to the criticisms from one of the Army’s most notable and well-respected leaders. For the Twitter reenactment, I will be doing a handful of the tweets as if I am tweeting from the social media team from the White House and a larger portion from Coolidge himself. Since Coolidge was not necessarily the most impactful president, I will maybe try to find a balance between being a context character, providing a character for the Billy Mitchell tweeters to make replies to, and overall attempting to seem to be avoiding the conflict and begrudgingly beginning to respond after pestering from Billy. Importantly, I will be responding after Coolidge is out of office and the country begins the Great Depression period, as someone who is apologetic and hoping to reconcile with the country who he led into financial failure.

Follow @POTUSCoolidge on Twitter.

Saturday, December 3, 2022

INTRODUCTION OF WILLIAM L. MITCHELL

Guest Post by Matthew G. Sadowski

December 29, 1879, in Nice, France, William l. Mitchell was born into the wealthy and powerful railroad, banking and political Mitchell family of Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Willie was raised on the sprawling John L. Mitchell and Harriet Danforth Becker Mitchell 240 acre estate of Meadowmere; an eastern portion of the current City of West Allis with the former family home now being part of the Mitchell Manor Senior Living Community.

 

Willie enjoyed the freedom that such a large estate could afford an energetic and inquisitive young boy of a family with immense wealth and privilege. Among his many interests, Willie occupied his time with activities such as hunting, fishing, raising chickens and horses and collecting bird specimens. Willie took these interests with him when, in the winter of 1890, after testing into the second form, Willie’s formal education began at the then-prestigious Racine College in Racine, Wisconsin. In addition to having respectable grades and usually perfect school conduct, Willie had an insatiable appetite for learning, exploring, fun and games, and like other classmates, a little bit of mischief.

 

Willie attended Racine College from January 1890 to June of 1895. During free times in barracks like dormitories, Willie was prolific at writing letters mainly to his mother, but later also to his father, then a US Representative and Senator. In his letters he reported on his many interests, activities, observations, and desires. Many of his activities were ordinary, but some were extraordinary.  While at Racine College Willie sang for a U.S. president, had discussions with a Civil War general, and walked with a captain of industry.

 

Two portraits of William Mitchell. A young Willie in the front left and over his shoulder a more mature man. In both portraits, Mitchell wears military gear.Willie could be very demanding in his letters, and very detail oriented, two traits he would carry into his highly decorated yet controversial career in the U.S. Army. However, in communicating with his mother and father Willie would always close his letters, no matter how demanding or frantic, using the words “love,” “respectfully,” or “truly”. It is unclear if such warmth was always conveyed in his written military salutations.

 

TWITTER HANDLE


As he grew older Willie came to be referred to as Billy, thus the Twitter handle being used for this reenactment will be WillieBillyM.